huh?

Posted By: deenibeeni on 2008-11-27
In Reply to: Anchor babies are natural citizens... sm - m

"Mr. Obama lived for 5 years in Indonesia, a country that does not recognize dual citizenship, therefore nullifying his American citizenship..."

So what if Indonesia doesn't recognize dual citizenship? Since when does living somewhere outside the U.S. mean you automatically forfeit U.S. citizenship? The only time his American citizenship would be nullified in a country that doesn't recognize dual citizenship would be if he became a citizen of that country. He lived there from age 6 to age 10.

"...IF it ever existed in the first place. There are no records on file where he ever applied for citizenship after returning to the US."

Right. Because he didn't have to. Because he didn't apply for Indonesian citizenship, & neither did his mother, & even if she had done this for him, he would likely have had the opportunity to have U.S. citizenship reinstated on reaching the age of majority.

Complete Discussion Below:

marks the location of current message within thread

Hopefully we will soon know - New Englander
- Delusional mob mentality cannot change facts. - Does it bother you in the slightest....sm
  - Delusional mob mentality? sm - dietcokedrinker
- Rest yourself assured that this is just more of the same...sm - oldtimer
  - Here - let me try to educate you on a couple of matters - New Englander
    - I meant why is everyone fighting (not defending) to let an independent party examine it. - New Englander
      - I would hazard to say....sm - m
- This is the most ignorant cr@p I've ever heard - gourdpainter
  - You wish - New Englander
    - Then talk to George W. Bush - gourdpainter
      - Well GW would be another whole post - New Englander
        Kenya has no business in the business of the U.S. - gourdpainter
        As always, let's just forget anything that - might look unfavorable
        Great post, GP. - Marmann
        I most certainly agree with you - gourdpainter
        What a coincidence! - Marmann
      - Then it would follow that .........sm - m
    - anchor babies are --- - Amanda
      - I don't think it's right but I think that's where we're headed. - gourdpainter
      - I'm perfectly fine with that. - New Englander
        THAT is the most insane statement I've ever heard! - gourdpainter
        Since the Constitution does not state - New England
        Thank you but I'm fairly familiar with the Constitution. - gourdpainter
        Answer - New England
      - I don't believe that the language of your parents. sm - m
        His MOTHER was a U.S. citizen - gourdpainter
        I know it does - his mother was underage citizen - We deserve the truth
        I have to ask - gourdpainter
        You see, GP can't find her *facts* to - quote on this so all of a
        Of course I wasn't - We deserve the truth
        Then you should consider saying - gourdpainter
        His sweet little Kenyan grandmother was there.... - m
        Then that would make him.........sm - m
        THANK YOU!!!!!!!!!! - We deserve the truth
        Alan Keyes- is a HATER and JEALOUS - underdog
        Why because he wants to find out the truth - Oh Pulllease
        You wouldn't recognize the truth - gourdpainter
        oh, but you would. - dnh
        It would appear that the likelihood of that happening....sm - m
        Charade - underdog
        Those 2 elections didn't leave a - gourdpainter
        thank you - I think I may know what's REALLY behind this..but... - underdog
        I think I know too but you're right - gourdpainter
  - Anchor babies are natural citizens... sm - m
    - Great post - thanks. - We deserve the truth
    - huh? - deenibeeni
      - Because........sm - m
        You can go to school as a legal resident - deenibeeni
    - sick bigoted hateful comments - underdog
      - Sick, bigoted and disgusting - gourdpainter
        obama - underdog
        There was nothing bigoted.........sm - m
        Most bigots deny it til their last breath. I think that they really don't know - they are bigots. nm
    - What I would like to see - gourdpainter
      - Did I say that I didn't have a problem......sm - m
        Change the subject? LOL - gourdpainter
        Yes.....changed the subject from Obama.......sm - m
        Please point me to the part of the - gourdpainter
        I'm working on that one............sm - m
        Well, crow is kinda tasty once you get used to it. LOL - gourdpainter
    - why would he have to apply for citizenship? He never denounced his citizenship... - Amanda
      - Because he had no citizenship to denounce in the first place. sm - m
        Just who gave Indonesia the right - gourdpainter
        He was never a US born American citizen - JEEZ - Do we have to repeat this
        I assume you were there at his birth? - gourdpainter
        obama - underdog
        just as you were? nm.. - dnh
        oh....you mean like...........sm - m
  - Obama has never shown his official certificate. - Why not? He could clear this up, but he wont.nm
    - I would say he has shown it to the people that he needed to -- nm - Amanda
      - and I would say - cj
      - I would say you are correct - gourdpainter

The messages you are viewing are archived/old.
To view latest messages and participate in discussions, select the boards given in left menu

Other related messages found in our database