Radiology Transcription vs Speech Recognition
Posted By: TheLadyInRad on 2005-12-27
In Reply to: Breaking into Radiology - Looking for a change
I have been doing radiology transcription now for 20 years. They say Radiology is usually the first speciality to go over the speech recognition usually - as it tends to be repetitious with usually a lot of "normals". Even with that said, most companies that do have radiology transcription are paying "by the report" these days, with most of the normals going to an automatic transcription system of some sort and the long reports (MRIs, CTs, Nuclear Medicine, invasive studies, etc.) still going to the transcriptionists. I have heard it said that it "averages out", but I'd be leary about signing up for say 96 cents to 1.35 (that seems to be about the range) to transcribe a report - no matter what the length these days, because it seems like there are no guarantees that the normals and shorter reports will still be going to the Transcriptionist and not to SpeechQ, inhouse, or speech recognition programs. I'd say check it out well before you "jump ship". The grass sometimes just looks greener on the other side. Only my 2 cents... Best of luck - whatever you decide to do.
... Lady
Complete Discussion Below: marks the location of current message within thread
The messages you are viewing
are archived/old. To view latest messages and participate in discussions, select
the boards given in left menu
Other related messages found in our database
i think it is automatic speech recognition but it is the same as VR which is voice recognition.
Voice recognition or speech recognition.
:
MQs speech recognition.
:
speech recognition
I worked with speech recognition at my last job and I didn't like it. It took longer and alot of mistakes came through. You were editing, but I found I could do a better and faster job typing it myself. Everyone's production went down and error rates went up because you become complacent and when you are reading along with the words playing in your ears your eyes have a tendency to overlook a lot of little things that should be edited. I did not find it productive or helpful just a mess.
Speech recognition
I am on speech recognition as it comes up. Don't have it all the time and it is on the DQS platform. I enjoy the break from typing but can be slow as you really have to listen to every word and make the corrections where necessary. The fastest typists just erase the entire report and retype. I just listen and make corrections. I have not had a pay reduction as of yet since this is not all I do. I am still paid my regular per line rate for SR but rumor has it that this will change but this is only a rumor, nothing in writing. If you do not like editing, can always tell them that you just want to type and not edit. I am on high speed internet also. Hope this helps.
Speech Recognition
Does anyone use speech recognition software for better transcription productivity? If so, I am interested in learning more about it & would like to talk. Thanks.
Speech recognition
I absolutely love editing speech recognition. After typing for 20 years, it definitely gives my hand a break. I like the pay as well.
Does anyone work with speech recognition? sm
We are currently learning this, and I hate it. It's not editing others' work, its doing your own transcription with speech rec. Does anyone else do this, and like it? Anyone had success with it, or failures? I'm seriously thinking of quitting my company, as we have to give this three months trial to get used to it, before we are considered for being taken out of the program.
All I hear from work is how wonderful it is, how positive, how everyone hates it at first but once you get used to it how you love it. I don't think so. This just isn't for me. There are others who feel the same way, but you never hear about them, unless you happen to stumble across those particular people somehow; which I have.
speech recognition sucks
They are selling it to docs and hospitals based on one thing only, it will cost them less money. Guess why?
It will cost US more money.
The only good thing I have to say about it is this: I know one of the major hospitals in my area is trying it and failing miserably.
They came out of the barn with this donkey a wee bit too early.
Automatic Speech Recognition (nm)
.
ASR question (speech recognition). sm TIA
For someone who transcribes roughly 250 LPH on acute care, what would the introduction of ASR due to her line count? Could she potentially increase it?
Back end speech recognition.
Can anyone tell me if this is a difficult job? Would this be much different than proofreading my own reports while listening to the sound file? What is the going line rate for something like that? Is it better pay than regular transcribing?
Thank to all who can soothe my nerves!!!!
question about speech recognition. sm
Do you need high speed internet for speech recognition? I've been informed by a company I edit for that they are going to incorporate speech recognition into ASP. I was also recruited by a company I recently left to rehire to do speech recognition. I can only get dial-up where I live. No DSL or cable. Could get satellite, but so many companies say no to satellite. Thanks!
Speech recognition platform. sm
The company is called MultiModal. They said they're going to integrate it with ASP. The other company I don't know.
Speech, or voice, recognition
nm
Has anyone tried Vista speech recognition?
nm
Speech recognition good or bad?
Is ASR using DEP/DocQscribe better than traditional transcription? What are the benefits & disadvantage of using ASR/DocQscribe? All input appreciated. Thanks.
Speech recognition discussion
In reading the news release posted below about Nuance buying escription, I was wondering how different SR platforms are working for us MTs. I do ASR on DQS and have found that on my main account the ASR is pretty good, so I don't have to make tons of changes.
I tend to like doing the speech recognition and here is why I think that is so in my case:
If I get my primary account it recognizes pretty well and I don't get much junk to have to change.
Also, I can usually turn the speed to the fastest whereas straight transcription is usually about the halfway point for me, so I think I am getting it done faster.
Another thing is that I never did get into the habit of really tweaking my Expander the way a lot of other MTs have. I have seen some say they put anything that takes more than 3 characters into an expander. I am getting better about this but not to that degree, so I think SR is faster for me.
I think I have some carpal tunnel issues starting up so I can't transcribe for as long a stretch as I can edit.
All that being said, about 25% of my work still comes through as straight transcription and it is a good thing because that significantly affects my hourly rate for the better, so I am not losing lots of $, although I have lost some.
So my question is two-fold: If you do SR, what system are you using? What has things specifically have made it better/worse for you?
The thing is, speech recognition is only
as good as the dictator dictating and the person reviewing the record before it is sent.
ASR = Automated Speech Recognition
MQ SPEECH RECOGNITION INFO WANTED
Hi,
Can someone who works for MQ and is on speech recognition give the rest of us some info as to what it is like, what the pay is, and whether or not a person would want to do it? It would be helpful info to have in case our office called and asked us if we wanted to be on that or not. I don't know if they have various speech recognition platforms, but I am on DQS and high speed internet.
Thanks
Speech recognition in court reporting
... You are right on. As I was doing my research into possibly getting into court reporting, low and behold, I find "voice writing" and VR coming into this field. This is impacting their profession also but at this time not to the degree VR has in MTing.
Speech to text recognition software
Can anyone give any information on a good speech to text recognition software?
Thanks..
Running Voice Files Through Speech Recognition. SM
Does anyone run their voice files (DSS and WMA) through a speech recognition program and then edit them? Just wondering if that is any faster than actually typing it myself. The doctor is a very clear dictator, so I'm wondering if the speech recognition would pick it up okay -- but wouldn't be able to teach the software to recognize her voice the way the instructions say to.
Also, does anyone using speech recognition listen to the dictation and then redictate it into speech recognition software themselves? I would be able to train the software to recognize my voice then.
Just trying to think of a few ways to increase my productivity and save my wrists at the same time. Thanks for any suggestions and comments.
Word 2003 speech recognition program
Has anyone heard of this or used it? I have Word 2003 and it has a built in speech recogition program that I did not know existed. From what I can see, I just have to download the software, purchase a microphone headset, and train the thing. Has anyone used this, is it proficient, and has it increased your transcription production. Also, I transcribe in ChartScript/NetLinc which is a Word-based program. For those who have used the speech recognition through Word would this work for me?
Radiology transcription, what type of reports are considered radiology
I have lot of experience with everything and I would like to know what exactly is considered radiology so I know if I qualify for that type of work? I've had many types that I think qualify for radiology.
speech vs. transcription
Thanks...I appreciate the input--I may just give it a try and see how it goes!:)
speech versus transcription
Hoping to find some input/wisdom here---I have been offered a positon where may of the accounts are partially voice rec--I have never edited this speech stuff--but I am wondering if you can make the same amount of $$ doing that as you can transcribing it--all the speech rates seem very low, around 4 cents a line--is it actually that much faster than transcribing? I would think it would be a lot quicker to actually do the transcription--has anyone any experience to share in this regard? thanks for any insight.....
Voice recognition - does anyone use this for their transcription??? sm
I know of a couple of transcriptionists that use this with the MT company I work with. They seem to struggle with it. Does anyone use VR? Just very curious if it helps production or if is more of a hassle to get it working right. Thank you very much in advance.
In transcription for recognition and helping humanity?
Ummm no. Money.
Voice recognition : Straight transcription
I could not agree more with what Lisa just said.
I really doubt that it takes less time. Because now you have t w o things to correct: The printed document that is in front of you on the computer - usually with a lot of mistakes - and at the same time 'figure' out what the doctor said.
Voice recognition makes a lot of mistakes, believe me.
First you read what the computer typed into the text document; then you have already the 'mistakes' in your head. Then you listen to the doctor's voice file. And you have to look terms up, too !
Very confusing, is this right or is that right? It does not go faster, no, because now you have three opinions:
1. That of the computer which typed the text document for you to correct and edit
2. The doctor's voice file 3. What you hear.
They only say it goes faster and is easier on the MT because they want to pay less. Except if the doctor speaks very, very, very cleary. Almost never the case.
And VR pays only h a l f of straight transription.
This is my experience till now!
I appreciate your comments, thanks!
Radiology transcription
There is an advertisement in my local paper for an inhouse transcriptionist, radiology experience preferred. I have about 6 years experience with family practice, also physical therapy, but very little radiology experience. Is this a difficult speciality to learn? Would I be wasting my time to apply?
Thanks--
Radiology Transcription
It is not a really difficult specialty to learn, but like anything else it does take time and experience to do it well. You probably have a decent background for trying it, but I wouldn't do it unless you are paid by the hour, at least for the first year or two. I have done radiology transcription for 15 years and love it, but another consideration is that it is usually one of the first specialties that is done by voice recognition technology, which limits the number of transcriptionists/editors needed. It looks like in the very near future radiology transcription will be best done by those already quite experienced with it...just a few things to think about.
radiology transcription
I have been doing radiology transcription for 19 years now and have radiology clients of my own - who do not intend to go with the voice recognition - some facilities do, will and have, but there are many radiologists who REFUSE to use the system.
How does one get into radiology transcription?
I've heard that it pays quite well. Is that true? Is there a crash or online course I can take to learn? Is it terribly difficult to learn? Also, if companies won't hire inexperienced rad MTs, how do you get the experience?
Radiology transcription
I have been an MT for 6 years doing only medical record transcription. I would like some feedback from individuals who currently do radiology transcription. Would it be difficult for me to learn if I've only done acute care? I see that many comment on this board reflect that a lot of people prefer radiology. What is it that you like about it? Is it easier than acute care?
Also, what is a good internet site to get sample reports?
radiology transcription
Hi all - I am new to this board and am a radiology/cardiology Transcriptionist that would like to find a work from home job with benefits. I currently work in a clinic setting, and prior to that worked in an acute care hospital setting. I have been reading the job seekers and company boards and am so confused as to who is a good radiology company to work for and who is not. Can anyone tell me a place that they like to work for? I would love to hear some positive feedback on good companies if anyone is willing to share. You can also email me if you would like. Thank you very much.
RADIOLOGY TRANSCRIPTION
I have been doing radiology for 11 years. In my opinion, radiology is very easy to learn if you remember that they ususually repeat in the impression what they say in the body of the report, so you have a couple of chances to catch something if you are not sure. Radiology is like any modality, might be difficult at first cause the rads have their own lingo, but once you get it, it is very easy. Good luck to you!
radiology transcription?
Does this high income also pertain to radiology?
Radiology transcription??
I don't see any other board to put this on. Hopefully this is the correct board. I have a question for radiology transcriptionists. I began transcription exclusively doing radiology and did it for 3 years, but that was almost 12 years ago. I have been doing acute care since then. My question is this. Has radiology changed much and do you think it would be possible for me to go back to doing radiology? I really enjoyed it a lot and hope the termininology hasn't changed too much in the last few years. Also, from what I am hearing it seems to pay a little better than acute care. Any comments and information will be greatly appreciated!
Radiology transcription
It does not allow as much flexibility as some other specialties - unless it is a huge hospital or group. I find it boring, but that is just me.
Radiology Transcription
If they offer per page, be aware of their font and margins. Ariel 10, 0.5" margins, will not pay you much per page. Tell them you will count your lines in Courier 12, 1" margins regardless of their font/margins. Only fair per page if short chest/extremity x-ray reports where you do not get any line count and make MORE per page, not LESS.
10-12 cpl 65 character line for MRIs, CTs, PETs.
Gross lines = Courier 12 font, 1 " margins. Don't let them quote you gross lines and then give you Arial 10, 0.5" margins. You will loose money.
These are ways you will be cheated by the services.
Radiology Transcription
I currently work for a hospital in NYC area. I have 30 years radiology transcription experience. I have experience in all modalities of radiology and also other areas such as cardiology, nuclear medicine etc. I am currently looking for a part time position at home, and I would be willing to be paid per line. On most occasions, I charge by the page. Please email me if interested. Thanks
radiology transcription
I have an interview tomorrow with a local hospital for a radiology position that is in-house. They outsource all of their other transcription. The job was advertised as per diem. I have about 10 years acute care experience, as well as some clinic work. I have done a bit of cardiology, but not really any radiology. Trying to get an idea if this is an easy transition, what to expect from per diem, any specific good questions to ask? Thank you so much for any input!
radiology transcription
Hi there: I made the transition from Clinic to Radiology and loved it. Have been typing radiology for 8 years now. I wouldn't change it for the world. Good luck.
Radiology transcription
If you don't mind I ask, who did you test for? Where I am currently working, they will be Laying off in approximately 1 month. (going to voice recognition). I am looking for another job in Radiology or Pathology but need benefits.
Radiology transcription for me
I dont know of any other field I could make the amount of money in a year that I make. I have tried acute care and clinic notes and find radiology the easiest. I rarely have to look up words.
I make over $80,000 a year working 6 days a week 10-12 hours a day and I dont think I could do that in any other type of transcription. I have several accounts that vary in pay range. I get .10/line on one account and 1.09/report for a VR account and two different accounts that pay by the report at $1.48 and 1.75 with the majority of the reports being x-rays.
there is a radiology transcription company in NY - but you
have to live in NY or NJ or even into CT or PA to work for them. But it has to be close to NYC.
PeachTree Radiology Transcription
I would like some information regarding Peachtree Transcription Associates that is based in metro Atlanta, Georgia.
Would someone who does radiology transcription be willing to answer--sm
a few questions for me and share some of their favorite web sites for research? Thanks
Sourcerad for radiology transcription
Hi,
Just wondering if anyone out there has used this system for transcribing radiology reports and if you could tell me about it, such as ease of use, likes dislikes, line counts, etc.
Mimi
|