Hopefully Katharine

Posted By: LinK on 2006-05-10
In Reply to: Chris all the way....sm - IdolFan as well.

I think Katharine should go based on last night. I didn't think she did very well at all. Loved Elliott last night. I still think it's going to be Taylor and Chris in the finals. For me, whoever goes home after Katharine now will make me sad. They're all so talented in my opinion.

Complete Discussion Below:

marks the location of current message within thread

What do you think this week? - IdolFan
- have you noticed that - crossing my fingers for Taylor
- Picking my jaw up off the floor - anon
  - You and Me Both - LinK
    - Me three!! sm - Chickadee
    - Also in shock....sm - IdolFan as well.
      - they were both in disbelief - speechless
- Hope to see Taylor go. Can't stand him. - nm
  - l love Taylor, I think he's a sweetie and seems genuine. - I hope he wins! nm
  - I know - how sickening is he???? - LOL
  - That;s how I feel about Chris (nm) - if I'm being honest
    - Well it really should be the best singer....after all... - And that is Chris, no question...sm
      - Very true...I was shocked as well - sm
  - DialIdol says Taylor got more votes than anyone. (nt) - I hope he wins!
    - That's only because of votefortheworst.com. nm - CMT
    - Me too... - Love Taylor...nm
- See ya Kat!!!!! I'm a sucker for the underdog which means..... (sm) - Mom_of_3
  - Idol this week - Another Idol Fan
    - touchy, touchy - Mom_of_3
      - Not really touchy, touchy - Another Idol Fan
        This is true..they'll have their chance - Claymate for Taylor
    - You know, she could have picked better songs - Claymate for Taylor
      - I agree - Mom_of_3
        I agree, also. Look at the one song Elliott did, - jus me
- I hope it's Katharine.....sm - My 2 cents worth
- Goodbye Katherine. I am rooting for Taylor..sm - AJ
- Adios Katherine - everyone else was good. - NM
  - Hope it's not Katharine - Another Idol Fan
- Taylor/Elliott finale would be my dream - Claymate for Taylor
  - what is zaba search? - idol fan...sm
    - Zaba (sm) - Claymate for Taylor
- Katherine has got to go. I also thought Elliott and Taylor ruled the night! - jus me
  - Chris all the way....sm - IdolFan as well.
    - Hopefully Katharine - LinK
    - I agree Taylor/Elliot. I think I would get bored with sm - IDOLFANALSO
      - Josh Who? - nm
        Josh - LinK

The messages you are viewing are archived/old.
To view latest messages and participate in discussions, select the boards given in left menu

Other related messages found in our database

I wish it was Katharine but we'll see...sm
I still think that someone at Fox made Simon and Randy apologize to her last week because they've never apologized for telling the truth in an analysis before.

Hope it's not Katharine
At the moment, I seem to be in the minority here, but I'm a big fan of Katharine's, and I don't think she should go. I like the remaining four, but Elliott is at the bottom of the list for me. I think he should go tonight or Taylor. I just don't see either of them as American Idols. Chris may win the competition, but I hope it's Katharine who does, as I have been betting on her all along. Chris is too hard rock for me, and he looked like a doofus in those sunglasses! Guess it's time for me to duck and run for cover!!!

I hope it's Katharine.....sm
and if she doesn't go then I reckon' Elliott would be my next choice to leave.

Katharine's Father
I was thinking the same thing about Katharine's father. They'll probably have to hold him up. All he does is cry whenever she sings. Imagine if she wins?

Katharine is my top pick by far. Fantastic all around. nm
x

I thought it was cool, and better than Katharine....
humping the floor for 3 minutes next to 2 big guys beating on a piece of luggage.

Katharine Close, the girl who just won the nat'l spelling bee. nm
x